Saturday, October 4, 2008
"exclusion and embrace" note 1
"But you've got to understand!" "I simply cannot understand this." "How they could do it is beyond me." "All I'm asking for is a little understanding here." Sounds familiar? People always yearn for understanding. But the longer I live, the clearer I see that the concept of mutual understanding will always be pretty much Utopian. In "Exclusion and Embrace", Volf proposes the "ability not to understand." He explains that the common problem with understanding the other may stem from the "desire to understand [them] ON THE SELF'S OWN TERMS, within the framework of its own reflexivity, whereas the other may not be understandable within the self's framework precisely on account of being the other" (p. 144, emphasis mine). He follows Gurovitch (1989: 163) in saying that the ability not to understand is "the ability to recognize and behold the other (...) as an other". Even more importantly, this ability is key in the process of reconciliation. Because its major part is precisely embracing the difference in the other instead of excluding it by casting them out.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
1 comment:
In some sense, "the concept of mutual understanding will always be pretty much Utopian" could be a correct statement. No finite being can ever truly get inside me, except God. Yes, a man may be possessed by a devil. But even that finite creature cannot fully understand me. It is only the infinite-personal God Who can.
Do we then stop communicating because no one understands except God? I can see where understanding can be stifled or mis-interpreted between two finite beings leading to exclusionary practices. I can also see where acceptance of the "other's" view can lead to embrace.
I guess I'm also seeking to understand others by their words and actions - as I'm sure they are with me. How far do we take this "ability not to understand"?
Simply a question to foster more discussion on your topic...
Post a Comment